Northlight · Before you commit

Before you spend anything, we try to break the plan.

We call it the hard look. Several people go at the thing you're about to build — deliberately from different angles, deliberately not the same angle twice — and you get back the specific ways it comes apart, in order, worst first. It's a list of what breaks, not a verdict on whether you'll succeed.

Ask for the hard look $750, and it comes off the build in full if you go ahead.
A week, start to finish. You keep the document either way.
$750one fixed fee, agreed before it starts
Off the buildcredited in full — the build price didn't move
A weekcall, then the document five working days later
Rankedworst first, by what it costs to be wrong
01What it is

Everyone checks whether it'll work. Almost nobody checks how it fails.

By the time a build has been agreed, everyone in the room has spent a fortnight talking about what it will do when it works. That is the easy half, and it is the half that gets all the attention. The expensive half is the other one: the supplier who sends the numbers as a PDF, the second location that does it a different way, the person who has been quietly fixing it by hand for three years, the software you already pay for that won't hand its data over without an upgrade.

Those are the things that turn a four-week build into a four-month one. None of them are secrets. They're just nobody's job to go looking for, because the person who could find them is the same person who wants it to go ahead.

So the hard look is somebody whose only job is to find them, before anyone has spent anything.

It doesn't tell you the plan will work. It tells you the ways it breaks, in the order they'd hurt. A prediction can be proved wrong six months from now. A list of the real risks is still useful even when the thing goes perfectly, because you spent the six months watching the right four things.

02How it's done

Four different arguments with the plan, not four goes at the same one

One reader looking for trouble finds the trouble they already had in mind. So the plan gets attacked several separate times, by readers briefed to care about completely different things, and none of them sees what the others wrote until they're finished.

The work as it actually runs

The exceptions, the manual step nobody documented, the customer who is handled differently because they've always been handled differently.

The systems it has to touch

What your existing software will and won't give up, what it costs to get at, and what breaks the next time it updates.

The people who have to use it

Who has to change how they work on Monday, who wasn't asked, and what everyone quietly goes back to when it's busy.

The worst plausible day

What happens when it's wrong, when it's down, when two people do the same job at once, and how long it takes anyone to notice.

Everything that comes back is put in one pile, the duplicates are merged, and then the rule that matters: anything nobody can check does not go in the document. If a finding can't be pinned to something you told us, something we can see in your systems, or something publicly true about the software involved, it gets dropped — however clever it sounds. A pre-emptive horror list is easy to write and worth nothing.

What survives that gets ranked, and not by how likely it is. By what it costs to be wrong about it — a small chance of something that stops the whole build outranks a near-certainty you'd fix in an afternoon.


03What you get

A document you could hand to somebody else

  • The ranked list. Every way we think this breaks, worst first, in plain English. No score out of ten, no traffic lights.
  • For each one: what it is, when you'd find out, and what it costs you to be wrong. Plus what would have to be true for it not to bite — so you can check it yourself rather than take our word for it.
  • What we'd do about each one. Sometimes that's a change to what gets built. Sometimes it's one question to ask a supplier before you sign anything.
  • The questions we couldn't answer from outside, written down as questions rather than guessed at. That list is usually the most useful page in it.
  • If you go ahead: a fixed price and a scope for the build, written after the hard look rather than before it — which is the only time a fixed price is honest.
  • Half an hour on the phone to go through it, and the document is yours whatever you decide. Take it to another studio if you like.

It's normally somewhere between four and eight findings. If it were twenty, most of them would be padding, and you'd stop reading before the one that mattered.


04What it costs

$750, and it comes off the build in full

$750 for the hard look. Builds still start at $4,500, and if you go ahead, the $750 comes straight off.

That is the whole arrangement. The build price is the same number it was before this page existed — we didn't put the build up to pay for the credit, which is the usual trick and the reason most people rightly assume a credited deposit is theatre. If you have the hard look and then build with us, the hard look has cost you nothing. If you have it and build with somebody else, or don't build at all, it has cost you $750 and you keep every page of it.

A call first

About forty-five minutes. Mostly us asking, and you'll know by the end of it whether this is worth doing at all.

Then five working days

That's the actual work. You don't hear much from us in the middle of it.

Then the document

Sent before the call about it, so you've read it properly and can argue with it.

Then it's yours

No retainer attached, nothing that renews, and no obligation to build anything.

The case where it costs you

Sometimes the honest finding is "don't build this yet"

It happens, and when it does there's no build for the $750 to come off. You've paid $750 to not spend several thousand more, which we'd argue is the cheapest version of that lesson available — but we're not going to pretend it's free, because it isn't.

And the same rule as everywhere else on this site applies before you've paid anything: if the honest answer is that a setting in software you already pay for fixes it, you'll hear that on the first call and there'll be no invoice.

05Honestly

What it will not tell you

Worth being clear about this before you pay for it, rather than after. Four things this is not, and one limit we can't get around.

It won't tell you this will work

We don't predict outcomes and we won't pretend to. Anybody selling you a confidence score on your own business is selling you a number they made up.

It isn't a market study or a business case

No revenue forecast, no payback period, no "this will save you X hours a week". We don't know your margins and we're not going to estimate them at you.

It can't be a complete list

Nobody can hand you every risk. We can hand you the ones we can find and stand behind, and tell you plainly where we stopped looking.

It won't be padded to look expensive

Anything we can't check gets cut, so the list is shorter than a scary one would be. That is a deliberate trade and you're paying for it.

The one thing it does tell you: where this goes wrong, what that costs, and what you'd do about it. Everything else on this page is us declining to sell you something we can't actually do.

06Why it's paid

The read is free and stays free. This one isn't.

The read is written from the outside, off what you can tell us in one box and what's already public. It costs you nothing, it asks for nothing, and it always will — that isn't a trial version of this page and it doesn't lead anywhere you have to pay to get to.

The hard look is a different thing. It needs your real numbers, a look inside the systems you actually run, and about a week of proper work at our end. Charging for it is the straightforward reason, and we'd rather say the other reason out loud too: a plan nobody has paid to question tends not to get questioned. Free advice gets read once and filed. A document somebody has paid for gets argued with, which is the entire point of it.

It also means we can afford to say the uncomfortable thing. Nobody who is hoping to be given a build is well placed to tell you not to have one.


07Proof

The first thing we did it to was us

Our website page has carried a guarantee for months: live within 48 hours of your photos, or your first month is free. It had been read, approved and left alone by everyone who looked at it, including us.

The same page also says, in bigger type, nothing to pay until it's live. So if we missed the 48 hours, the penalty was refunding a month nobody had been charged for yet. A promise that reads like a promise and costs the person making it precisely nothing.

Nobody had complained. Nobody had noticed. It took one reader whose only job was to attack the offer about ninety seconds. The line now reads the first month after it goes live is on us, which is a thing we can actually be held to — and you can go and check that it says so.

That's the shape of what this finds. Not a disaster. The thing everybody had already read a dozen times and nobody had checked.

What we're not claiming

No client has bought one of these yet

This is a new thing and we've run it on our own work, not for a paying customer. There are no case studies on this page because there are none to tell, and we'd rather the first thing you read about us was true than impressive. When there is one, and when the client is happy to be named, it'll be here with their name on it.

What you can check today is the rest of it: six pieces of software we built and still run, and a free read you can have in two minutes without giving us an email address.

08Start

Send us the plan, badly described

A paragraph is enough: what you're about to build or buy, who has to use it, and roughly when. If you've already had a read from us, just reply to it and say you want the hard look. We'll come back with whether there's one worth doing here — and if there isn't, we'll say so and there's nothing to pay.

$750, one fixed fee, agreed before anything starts. Credited in full against the build if you go ahead. Nothing is invoiced until we've both agreed it's worth doing.

Not ready for that? Have the free read instead — one box, your own words, no email address, and it'll tell you if you don't need us at all.